Manchester's "third" orchestra hasn't had the recognition it deserves. Under Douglas Boyd it has produced a terrific set of Beethoven symphony recordings, to which this is a resounding conclusion. Its chief quality is its massive sense of energy. Beefy without being bloated, Boyd's interpretation is particularly good at sustaining momentum in fast movements. Weaknesses? The chorus sounds slightly anemic in places and the solo singers have harsh moments. But a credit to all - and further evidence that Boyd has serious credentials on the podium.